What We're About

Simply Sarah Nicole Jewelry is a clay earring and necklace shop located in Northern Florida. We use a mix of polymer clay and metals to create versatile jewelry that you can throw on with jeans and a t-shirt or dress up and wear to a wedding. We know that high quality jewelry is a priority which is why in all of our jewelry we use nickel-free and hypo-allergenic metals. Plus, polymer clay is extremely lightweight and makes the earrings so comfortable you'll forget you're even wearing them! At Simply Sarah Nicole Jewelry we strive to create pieces that never put you in a place where you have to compromise between style and quality!

My Story
  • Noel

    Regular price $28.00 USD
    Regular price Sale price $28.00 USD
  • Holly Wreath

    Regular price $28.00 USD
    Regular price Sale price $28.00 USD
    Holly Wreath
  • Diana (Snowflake)

    Regular price $28.00 USD
    Regular price Sale price $28.00 USD
    Diana (Snowflake)
  • Snowflake Hoop

    Regular price $24.00 USD
    Regular price Sale price $24.00 USD
    Snowflake Hoop

Frequently Asked Questions

Are Clay Earrings Heavy?

Nope! Unlike traditional ceramic clay, polymer clay is super lightweight, flexible (so they won't break if you drop them), and easy to wear!

What If I Have Sensitive Ears?

All of the metal used in Simply Sarah Nicole Earrings is nickel-free and hypo-allergenic which makes them a great option if you have sensitive ears! Plus, polymer clay is so lighweight you won't have to worry about sore ears!

How Does Shipping Work?

Shipping will be calculated at check out and will be adjusted for your location! If you are in the Jacksonville, FL area you can select the local pick-up option!


Nook + Nest - Ames, IA

Innovate 1858 - Ames, IA

Oak Lane Candle Co. - Ames, IA

Local Supply Co. - Huxley, IA

Charlotte Louise Merchantile - Ankeny, IA

Funky Zebra- Ankeny, IA

Trixie Salon and Spa - Des Moines, IA

Porch Light - Des Moines, IA

Hinge on 5th- Des Moines, IA

emBellish - Pella, IA

Mint Green Boutique - Davenport, IA

Fresh Home & Lifestyle Market - Muscatine, IA

Bluejay Boutique - Danbury, IA

Gypsey Quarter - Centerville, IA

Guided Grace - Sioux Center, IA

Grace and Strength Boutique Clear Lake, IA

Sweet Charlotte Vintage Finds- Plano, IL

Revival - Waupaca + Neenah, WI

Porch Light - Portland, OR

Coconut Barrel - Saint Augustine, FL

Linen and Wood - Amelia Island, FL

The Poppy Seed - DeForest, WI